We'll have some more post-mortem stories and a mailbag, but I'd thought I'd post some candid thoughts on the 2024 roster.
I'll post thoughts on the defense in a separate thread.
An early look at the projected Illinois football depth chart for 2024.
illinois.rivals.com
Overall, Illinois should have a good offense next season. They were fourth in the Big Ten in total offense this year and return a solid foundation. Any time you return a talented starting quarterback, you have a chance. Piecing together a solid OL is a key.
QUARTERBACK: Illinois is in solid shape at the quarterback position, but I'm not sure if all scholarship quarterbacks will return. QB's like to find a place where they can start. Luke Altmyer is the starter for the next two seasons if he stays healthy. He'll be a good quarterback in the Big Ten. There are some concerns about his feel for the pocket, but the experience this year should help.
They love incoming recruit Trey Petty and think he's the future starter post-Altmyer. The biggest knock on Petty is his size. He has a good enough arm, though, and like Altmyer he can make plays with his feet. He's actually more of a natural runner than Altmyer. If one of the other QB's hit the Portal, they may want to add another backup as they did last year with Paddock. They would be comfortable with Donovan Leary as QB2, though.
RUNNING BACK: I'm not as high on this group as some people are. As a unit, they lack speed and quickness. Ca'Lil Valentine will help. If he can add a few pounds between now and next fall he should be ready to play early. Reggie Love has the option of coming back for a fifth year. He was introduced with the seniors on Saturday and I haven't heard any buzz yet on which way he's leaning.
Kaden Feagin is obviously very talented, but what do you do with him? I worry about his long-term health. He's going to get hurt if all you do is pound him inside. I want to see him in space more, both on stretch plays and throwing to him out of the backfield. He's a good player, but you don't want him to have an old man's body by the time he's a junior.
Aidan Laughery lacks good enough vision to be an every-down back. That's holding him back in terms utilizing his speed. He'd do better as an all-purpose guy that you spread out wide on occasion. Josh McCray is a candidate to transfer, IMO. He was ineffective when healthy, and he's obviously not durable. I don't know what they have in Jordan Anderson yet. He's a big power back like Feagin. Before he got hurt, I thought a move to H-back might help him. He was having a pretty camp when he injured his knee.
Get this group healthy and see what you have in the spring. Feagin, Love, Valentine, could potentially be a pretty good RB room.
WIDE RECEIVER: The ICON collective should be working diligently on a package to try to retain Isaiah Williams. I'm not yet sure how receptive he will be, but there should be pretty good NIL$ for him.
Overall, the receiver room as some potential. The younger guys are more quick-twitch than the veterans who played this year. Kenari Wilcher and incoming freshman Tysean Griffin should be solid slot receivers if Williams doesn't come back. I actually like Griffin better on defense at corner, but they want the ball in his hands. Hank Beatty is a backup, spot player, and special teams guy.
On the outside, Ashton Hollins has more speed than Pat Bryant and Casey Washington. He still needs more muscle but is a willing blocker. They will miss Washington's route running and contested catches. He put on a clinic against Northwestern. Bryant and Hollins should be the starters.
JUCO transfer Mario Sanders was prolific at IWCC. He was just named the conference offensive player of the year after posting 926 receiving yards and 12 TD's.
There has been buzz all season about Malik Elzy potentially hitting the Portal if he doesn't play. He's talented and is a key cog, so his departure would be a blow. We will see what unfolds in the next few days. Shawn Miller played sparingly. Same as Eian Pugh. Collin Dixon took a redshirt. Recruit Carlos Orr is similar to Bryant. Good size but not particularly speedy. JUCO transfer Alexander Capka-Jones was a bust.
TIGHT END. TE is a team weakness, especially if Tip Reiman doesn't use his extra year and come back. They don't have a guy who is both a solid blocker and good receiver, so they have to mix and match depending on the package.
Tanner Arkin and Griffin Moore are strictly receivers. Henry Boyer is a blocker who is limited to stick routes and quick outs in the passing game. His career would have a higher trajectory if he beefed up and played tackle, but he doesn't want to do that. Owen Anderson and Nate Gunn didn't see the light of day.
Of all of the TE's they will have on the roster, incoming freshman Karsen Konkel may have the most upside. He's a huge kid and excellent athlete, but very raw. I don't know what to expect from Tanner Hollinger. He played 8-man football in Nebraska and dominates, but his film and stats don't mean much, IMO. We'll see.
OFFENSIVE LINE: The O-line could be okay, but they have holes to fill. I do have confidence that Bart Miller will find a way to make it work. He showed his coaching chops in fixing it this year when things were going south fast. I think he will put together a solid starting five, but how much depth they have will depend on developing some of the younger guys who haven't played yet. I also think there will be some attrition, so they may need multiple guys from the Portal / JUCO ranks.
The offseason priority is finding a starting right tackle. They will be aggressive recruiting JUCO's and transfers. They don't want to move Josh Gesky or Zy Crisler back outside, but its an option in a pinch. Brandon Henderson will start at left tackle. He has the natural talent to be a future NFL Draft pick. It's a big offseason and spring for him.
Although they were pretty happy with Josh Kreutz at center this season, I'd like to see more size at the position. Kreutz could get pushed in the spring by TJ McMillen, who was a top recruit in the 2023 class. They also may want a transfer who has the versatility to play some center.
They are in pretty good shape on the inside. Gesky and Crisler both return at guard. Although we don't for sure what the best position is yet for junior college transfer Dez'Mond Shuster, he looks the part of a guard at 6-5, 345. If he can play and excel at right tackle, that would be a big plus. Zach Barlev and Hunter Whitenack are solid backups. Whitenack got three starts this year.